The Painter’s Daughter by Julie Klassen #SweetDelight

Posted March 13, 2016 by Sophia Rose in Sweet Delight / 18 Comments

I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review.
This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

The Painter’s Daughter by Julie Klassen #SweetDelight
The Painter’s Daughter

One StarOne StarOne StarOne Star

Genres: Historical Romance, Inspirational Romance
Published by Small Publisher
Released on December 1, 2015
Pages: 464
Format: Paperback
Source: Publisher

Get it at: add to goodreads

I read my first book by this author just last year and definitely wanted to read more so I was pleased to snag this one.  While this book had different elements and went a different direction, I found it easy to engage with the story.  I liked how the book began with a young woman’s mistake and followed along as events took their course to her again faced with a choice and seeing how she faced it this time.

The story begins with Sophie Dupont, daughter to a successful portrait painter, caught in a bad situation.  The man she loves and thought was going to propose marriage has left her behind to pursue his art.  Her mistake has consequences and she is pregnant.  And there offering her rescue is her lover artist’s younger brother.  Where Wesley is fair, pleasing, and handsome in his ways, this tall, stern-expressioned dark stranger is his opposite.  He is a soldier and his volatile nature unsettles her, but it is either take Captain Stephen Overtree’s offer of marriage of convenience or lose her reputation and destroy any chance of a respectable reputation of her unborn child.  By taking the Captain, she will be forced to give up on Wesley.  But as she spends time in Captain Stephen Overtree’s company and care, she begins to compare the two brothers and which one has stood steadily beside her and did his best to place her first even if he is reserved and quiet and never promised her love.

Stephen has come searching out his older brother to bring him back to the family estate to take up his neglected responsibility as heir and help their ailing father since Stephen has to return to his regiment and can no longer shoulder Wesley’s responsibility.  Except when he tracks Wesley to beautiful Devon, he finds that once again he is left to clean up one of Wesley’s messes and shoulder responsibility.  Stephen makes the offer that his brother should have made to the woman who fell for his fickle brother’s charms and he must hide from her that while she pines for Wesley that Stephen has held her miniature portrait close to him for over a year and dreamed about the woman his brother used as a model.  He is a soldier and believes that he is fated to die so he is at peace with his maker and content to have rescued Sophie.  He tries to not wish for more than she can ever give him.

This was a story that I struggled with in the beginning.  I wasn’t really fond of Sophie.  She messed up and really has no choice, but she chose to act like Stephen was the bad guy when he was really her hero.  Eventually, she gets a clue about how selfish and self-absorbed she is being and that helped me enjoy the story more.  There is a strong religious thematic element running through it so this might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but I found it a sweet, heartwarming story.  There is internal and external conflict.  Even a love triangle which I usually detest, but didn’t mind in this one.  It is a slow build and slow burn that has some good foreshadowing and hints to keep it from dragging as it sets up for the more intense and faster-paced ending.

The characters are interesting.  Stephen is very religious, but not in a sanctimonious way.  He lives what he believes even if he isn’t as easy on the eye or as silver-tongued as his brother.  No, he isn’t perfect, but he does try to do the right thing.  He has the struggle of duty and honor before what he would prefer and being attracted to a woman who prefers his brother.  His parents even favor his brother falling for his charms though his old nurse and grandfather do not because they see through Wesley.   His brother disappoints him often, but he also loves him.  There is a bit of Cain and Abel thing going on mostly on Wesley’s end.

Sophie isn’t religious, but she was naive and had romantic notions in the beginning.  She saw the glamour of Wesley and heard his beautiful words with no real substance.  Felt the connection of their mutual love of art.  She hasn’t had an easy life after losing her mother, having her artistic work under-appreciated and downplayed, and being stuck with a mean step-mother and a sneaky, greedy man who is her father’s apprentice.  It was easy to see how she fell for Wesley.  I enjoyed following along as she slowly learned to appreciate her husband, Stephen.  The author didn’t make it quick and easy which I appreciated.  Sophie’s feelings had to change as she learned the difference between flash and substance.

The story also included some mild suspense with a mystery in the Overtree family home and there was the nail-biting situation when Stephen was called back to war and fought in the final defeat of Napoleon that resulted in a large loss of life leaving the family wondering if Stephen was one of these even while Wesley has returned and left Sophie with the angst-wrought dilemma of choosing between the brothers.

On a side note, the attention to historic detail and the fun nods toward Jane Austen were added enjoyment.  A woman artist and the time period of England at war were strong and engaging elements.

In summary, it started shaky, but then grabbed my attention.  Loved the flawed characters and the well-developed romance and story.  I said it before, but I like the author’s writing style and plan to hit her backlist and continue with her new releases.  I would recommend this one for those who enjoy inspirational sweet historical romance.

My thanks to Bethany House Publishing for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Challenges Met:

Romance Roundabout #75 HR
Literary Pickers #73 Arranged Marriage
Mt. TBR #35

About Julie Klassen

JULIE KLASSEN loves all things Jane–Jane Eyre and Jane Austen. A graduate of the University of Illinois, Julie worked in publishing for sixteen years and now writes full-time. Her books have been honored with the Christy Award for Historical Romance, the Minnesota Book Award, and the Midwest Book Award, among others. Julie and her husband have two sons and live in a suburb of St. Paul, Minnesota. For more information, visit

The following two tabs change content below.
I was born and raised near Sacramento, CA. I have read since I was four years old and developed tastes that run the gamut of literature. I went away to college and have a degree in education, a certificate in family history research, and a certificate in social work. I worked for a non-profit agency with low income families for 20 years which included being responsible for the children’s library and promoting/teaching adult literacy. I have lived in Southeast Michigan for the last 18 years and I am currently a book addicted homemaker with a cat and husband who keep me grounded. Recently, I made it a challenge to review each book that I have read as a favor to author friends who said reviews are important. I have done reviews for Good Reads, Amazon, eBay, and Smashwords, but mostly at Goodreads and Amazon.

Tags: , , ,

  • Not really a fan of Sophie

    • She sure did make it tough for me to get into her story at first. I was a Stephen fan.

  • dholcomb1

    sounds like a nice story

    • It was sweet and a nice change up. I like the author’s writing and attention to historical detail behind the sweet romance.

  • I almost requested this one, but I stopped myself. Now I wish I had. Nothing pleases me more than some flawed characters. Great review!

    • LOL! I do that frequently- a book looks good, but I talk myself out of it usually b/c I already have a pile to read.

  • I have this in my tbr pile. Glad to see your review. Looks like one I will enjoy when I get to it.

    • Look forward to seeing what you think when you get the chance to read it.

  • I don’t read religious fiction often at all. It has been probably more than 5 years since I picked up this genre but I think I might actually have a couple of Julie Klassen’s books in my kindle account. I am glad you enjoyed this one. Great review!

    • I don’t read it often either, but there are a few authors that I enjoy and gladly pick up their stories. This is only my second Klassen, but I think I’ll eventually go back and read her others. Hope you enjoy the one’s you’ve got, Carole! 🙂

  • RO

    I’m woefully behind on my reading, but a man with the type of hero character development and the religious overtones definitely make me want to pick this one up. Sounds really unique. Your review is right on point and love it! Hugs…RO

    • Your words mean a lot, Ro. Yes, Stephen was the highlight of the story for me. I liked the combo of quiet strength and spirituality.

  • Debbie Haupt

    This looks good Sophia Rose, thanks!

    • It was a sweet read and I enjoy the change up between my others.

  • Whew that would annoy me early on with her, I think. I bailed on one like that recently (the Greenwood one) where the heroine acted put out by the hero doing the right thing. I’m glad to hear she figured things out! I think I would like Stephen’s character quite a bit. I’ll have to check it out just for him I think 😀

    • Oh, yeah, I remember what you said about the Greenwood one. This one’s not as bad though yes, she teeters in that direction. Stephen was strong and mostly patient with Sophie. I liked him for that.

  • LorenDushku

    Thank you for your review Sophia! I definitely want to read this book!

    • Oh good! Glad you want to read it now, Loren. Hope you like it. Look forward to seeing what you think if you get the chance.