Review: Falling In by Lydia Michaels

Posted October 24, 2014 by Sophia Rose in Reviews / 14 Comments

I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review.
This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Review: Falling In by Lydia Michaels
Falling In

One StarOne StarOne StarOne StarHalf a Star

Series: #1 Surrender Trilogy
Genres: Erotic Romance
Published by Berkley
Released on October 7, 2014
Format: Paperback
Source: Publisher

Get it at: add to goodreads

This was such a unique story when it came to the hero and heroine’s situations- a billionaire and a person who is homeless- that I just had to see where it went. I have never read anything by this author so I found that another good reason. Plus, I knew going in that this is part of trilogy that reads more like one book broke into three volumes- so lots of time to develop the characters, the relationship and the plot. And it did all that from right away.

Okay, elephant in the room stuff. I’ve seem this series compared to Fifty Shades of Gray. Yes, our hero is a conflicted, moody, sensual sexually dominant billionaire and yes, our heroine is a sexually submissive virgin with very little sexual knowledge and yes, there is a traitor friend and a sense that things are going to get real in book two, but I think leaving it at that is only a bit of the answer. It also has many points that make it quite a bit different from the other series. The personalities of the characters, the development of their relationship and the surrounding plot threads give it a whole different feel. From cover to cover, I totally forgot there ever was the FSoG series because this one captivated my attention in its own right.

Also, this book does end abruptly and on an ominous note, but there is no huge cliffhanger and the main part of the story concludes in a good place while still leaving me eager to dive into the next segment.

Alrighty, the story begins with a young woman, Evelyn ‘Scout’ Keats, a homeless gal with nothing, but strong ambitions to get out of her situation. She has finally caught a break. She has a cleaning job with a posh hotel and now she comes face to face with the owner when she accidentally knocks over the paper stack on his desk while cleaning his suite. She thinks the cold-eyed brooding man who watches her like she’s a thief will have her fired by morning. Instead, she gets a startling proposition from him. He outlines an emotionless liaison between them with expectations and rules because Scout catches his eye and intrigues him as different. There is nothing in Scout’s experiences of living on the streets to compare to what he is offering nor can she run this past her friend, the enigmatic Parker, because he doesn’t share her ambition to get off the streets and find something stable.

She is fearful, but Scout eventually agrees with strong reservations knowing that Lucian Patras will expect a whole lot more that goes beyond what she can fathom or understand. She’s never let anyone touch her and she knows Lucien will not wait long for that. It is everything else that is part of Lucien’s world that makes her feel so off-balance too. Lucien doesn’t help either the way he swings from friendly and gentle to distant and angry with her when she doesn’t even know what caused it. It shames her to see how others regard her when they see her with Lucien. Nobody thinks for a second that she is with Lucien because she wants to be with him as a man and not a man with money. They are so different and this causes her many times to pick up her backpack and get ready to leave, but finally enough is enough. He’s hurt her too badly this time and she’s done. Scout disappears back into the streets leaving Lucien sorrowing and then frantic to find her even as he learns that her homeless shelter has been closed down and she truly is on the streets in the middle of winter. He has learned through her absence what he couldn’t see before. He needs and wants her desperately- he has come to love Evelyn ‘Scout’ Keats.

Much of this story is a steady rise and fall of two broken people finding their way to be together and be what the other person needs. They come from vastly different circumstances in some ways, but in others they share a similar past that leads to an understanding that is the basis of their relationship.

I really appreciated the work the author did in detailing out the life of a homeless person so that there is a greater appreciation for just how hard it was integrating into the work as a domestic let alone into Lucien’s world. The portrayal is real, moving, and leaves the people of that class their dignity. Well done, Ms. Michaels from the heart of a former rescue mission worker! The juxtaposition of this against the glittering life of the penthouse of a five star hotel with a billionaire was fascinating and really had me admiring Scout.

That brings me to the heroine. Loved what I saw in this intrepid woman. The phrase ‘came from the gutter’ is literal in her case and she has risen so far above it just by staying clean from drugs and alcohol and sex with her hope and dreams intact. Even when others don’t believe in her, she believes in herself. She had pride and gumption to go along with her feelings of inferiority and fear that it would all go away leaving her with nothing. She is so open to Lucien and it was hard watching him crush her each time not even realizing how much damage he was doing because he never suspects her background and their almost foreign worlds that have collided.

As tempting as the offer of fine clothes and salon beauty treatments were, she was more concerned with proper-fitting shoes she could take with her when Mr. Patras no longer required her ‘company’. Her situation in life had never, not once, allowed for any sort of indulgence. Scout’s brain simply wasn’t wired in a way that permitted such fantasies.  p.45 Scout, Falling In

She might have been submissive in the sense that she wanted to please him particularly in the bedroom, but this did not translate to doormat. She made it clear that he could not treat her as an object to be picked up or sat down at will and he couldn’t play games with the rules or her feelings. She did the job and brought out the best in him.

Now Lucien, was a bit more of a mystery. He is filthy rich and has the attitude to match. He is ruthless and cold much of the time. He grew up as parent-less as Scout so they have that in common. Nobody except maybe his friend Jamie has a clue who the real Lucien is. Scout gets glimpses of lots of sides to him, but only she sees some of them.

Scout picked up the sponge and washed his arms and hands. Beautiful strong hands, so different than the hands she had washed that afternoon. “I don’t have many friends,” she said, not sure where the words came from.
He kissed the moist skin below her ear, “Me neither.”
“What an odd pair we are…”
“Not odd,” he said introspectively. “Just finding our way. It’ll be easier now that we have each other’s company.”
p. 175 Scout and Lucien, Falling In

His darker tastes in the bedroom both titillate and make her nervous. He might have set the rules, but she has her own set of rules too and now for the first time, Lucien wants to break the rules and put himself out there for a woman. Gaining Evelyn/Scout’s trust and her love along with possessing her completely is his goal. Scout might have transformed physically into Evelyn, but Lucien’s spiritual and emotional transformation was even bigger. There are flashes of his backstory with the two other men he associates with and a woman two of them shared that I hope with get teased out in the ongoing story.

Now the story wasn’t all Lucien and Scout’s growth and hot romance. There are some promises of trouble building particularly toward the end of the book. Lucien’s love for Scout is a first time for him and its a consuming thing that I suspect might cause some problems for the skittish Scout who is not as far along that path as Lucien. There is also a suspense element. There is a ticking time bomb to all Lucien’s plans because he has made two serious enemies and he owes one of them a favor that one of the enemies plan on collecting taking Lucien’s very source of happiness, Scout, away from him.   I can’t wait to see where this part of the story goes and how Scout will react when she learns about this deal.

The erotic part of the book really doesn’t get going until the second half when the two make up for lost time. It builds from warm to scalding hot as Scout leaves her virgin status behind. Lucien is demanding, but he is also patient too. They work with a safe word and explanation when they get deeper into the physical relationship. I know it probably shadows toward BDSM, but it didn’t quite have all the earmarks of it just yet and felt more like two people getting their kink on in the bedroom. For those wondering, I’d put it in the mild category of BDSM as there was spanking, anal sex and one moment of mild voyeurism. There is a D/s tone to their sexual relationship that gets stronger toward the end.

I’ll be honest, the only part of this story that gave me a niggle was the physical relationship in the first half of the book. I was nervous when Scout said yes to his proposition, but lied by omission that she knew what she was doing and implied that she was sexually active when clearly she knew nothing and was not. She put him in a bad spot and made the guy feel like he ravished her in a bad way then didn’t seem to understand why he backed way off. I get why she felt she couldn’t come clean, but it bugged me until the truth was out so that Lucien knew what he was up against and could alter things accordingly.

So, in the end, this was a fabulous read for me that had me squirming from the heat and totally vested in Lucien and Scout’s story. This one is for those who enjoy slow to build, character driven, erotic romance.

My thanks to Penguin Group for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

The following two tabs change content below.
I was born and raised near Sacramento, CA. I have read since I was four years old and developed tastes that run the gamut of literature. I went away to college and have a degree in education, a certificate in family history research, and a certificate in social work. I worked for a non-profit agency with low income families for 20 years which included being responsible for the children’s library and promoting/teaching adult literacy. I have lived in Southeast Michigan for the last 18 years and I am currently a book addicted homemaker with a cat and husband who keep me grounded. Recently, I made it a challenge to review each book that I have read as a favor to author friends who said reviews are important. I have done reviews for Good Reads, Amazon, eBay, and Smashwords, but mostly at Goodreads and Amazon.

Tags: , ,

  • Oh my gosh! Sophia I just read one with a (not sure he was quite a billionaire but way way well off) hero and a homeless heroine with a criminal arrest in her past. It was crazy different.

    I’d passed this one up and kinda regretting that now. Not loving that 50 shades ref/cover (I just don’t like that marketing trend) but it sounds pretty great. The heroine sounds wonderful. Alright adding it to my list.

    • Yeah, the cover was supposed to make sense once you read the story. Maybe its just me being dense, but I never did see the connection other than yes, there’s water and ice in the book since its winter. I really do like it when a cover matches the book and isn’t just trendy. I kept thinking of Pretty Woman when I read this, but these two are darker and more damaged so Richard Gere and Julia Roberts could have totally rocked the cover.

      Hey, I didn’t think I’d get into a broody billionaire story, but I did so if you think of the title of the one you read, I’d love to know.

      • LOL just seeing the cover I can’t imagine how it would be related to something at all in a major way.

        Oh that coulda been a very neat cover if gone in that direction. Ah well.

        The one I read is out first week in Nov. The Mistress Experiment by Elizabeth Otto. It’s her first one that’s more adult themed. Her others have been with Entangled and were great but more mainstream-ish though really this one wasn’t too out there. I had a good time with it. Ended up reading until like 3 in the morning. lol

        • Okay, I’ll check out her book. You know, I haven’t figured out some times what makes a book just hot romance and what makes one erotic romance some times. I mean, yes, I get it if there is kink like the one I read here, but I’ve read some contemporary and historical stuff where its descriptive and they’re going at it like monkeys every other page, but its not listed as erotic. But I’ve also read books listed as erotic that have less sex and even less descriptive sex to boot.
          Anyhoo, sorry, chased that white rabbit that was a little off your point about the adult-themed and mainstreamish stuff.

          • LOL it is weird sometimes. I’ve had those too where totally mainstream reads and WHOA! they’re hot. Some even have light bdsm elements yet still considered reg mainstream romances. And yeah have had some of the erotic ones where I’m going, erm, we ever gonna get to the naughty? lol Sometimes I think it’s just subject matter or words used for parts. It’s weird.

            • Must be! I don’t mind b/c I love a variety in the heat factor, but I could see how this would be frustrating for someone who preferred one end of the spectrum over the other.
              Haha! You sound like me when an erotic is…well, underwhelming and long on promise. ‘kay, lots of character and story development- and lots more, well sure love that, but um…oh, oh, there it is don’t blink. It’s gone again. Patience…virtue…yada yada.

              • ::snort:: Yup that would be how it goes here. lol The “new” Roni one kicks things off pretty darn quick. It’s been great so far 🙂

                And yup I’m with you. I like the variety. Only a couple times have I been too disappointed when I expected one and got something else. But most of the time I’m good with just going with it 🙂

                • Oh that’s good. Are you reading the serial one or are you on that one releasing in Jan. I got them both, but I’m just starting the serial one.

                  Oh btw, things moved along a bit better for that Balogh in the end though it was tough waiting that long for the fun and fireworks. I’m hoping that this was just b/c she chose to do an actual Survivor Club meet up as her background instead of starting with the usual action-ish plot that brings the h/h together.

                  • Good to hear about the Balogh. I’ll hopefully get back to it at the end of the week. I have one more from my Nov stash from them (Shannon K Butcher) after finishing Roni’s then I’ll attempt the Balogh again.

                    I’m working on Roni’s serial. I’ve got about 100 pages left and really liked it so far. Great heroine. There’s a bonus novella at the end too I didn’t realize was there. I can’t wait for the Jan book. I haven’t grabbed it yet but plan on it. 🙂

                    • Okay, just so I don’t rouse strong anticipation, when I say action, that’s relative to the first half of the book. It’s more like clashes with other characters and getting everything out in the open that was hidden before. Haha!

                      Oh, a novella too! That’s cool. I wasn’t expecting that. Maybe its the one that I haven’t read yet or even better a new one I didn’t even know about.

                    • ::snort:: Thanks for the warning Sophia. lol

                      Yes I wasn’t expecting the surprise story either! It’s a brand new one that’s for the hero’s old friends with benefits. Apparently a lot of people really were curious about her after reading the serial last year so she included that in the print.

                    • Oh cool! She really does listen to readers. The last novella was b/c tons of people wanted a follow-up on Melt into You. I was one. Now this, yay for Roni!

                    • That really is pretty awesome. Be prepared on this one. The last few chapters tissues are gonna be needed. Tears everywhere. Like dripping off the chin tears. Lordy! I’m feeling a bit hungover now. lol Gonna do errands to settle then jump into the novella. Whew!

                • Oh that’s good. Are you reading the serial one or are you on that one releasing in Jan. I got them both, but I’m just starting the serial one.

                  Oh btw, things moved along a bit better for that Balogh in the end though it was tough waiting that long for the fun and fireworks. I’m hoping that this was just b/c she chose to do an actual Survivor Club meet up as her background instead of starting with the usual action-ish plot that brings the h/h together.