Brooklyn On Fire by Lawrence H. Levy

Posted January 18, 2016 by Sophia Rose in Reviews / 16 Comments

Tags: , , ,

I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Brooklyn On Fire by Lawrence H. Levy
Brooklyn On Fire

One StarOne StarOne StarHalf a Star

Series: #2 Mary Handley Mysteries
Genres: Historical Romance, Romantic Suspense
Released on January 19, 2016
Pages: 352
Format: eARC
Source: NetGalley
add to goodreads

I was looking for a little something different from my usual romantic suspenses and mysteries set in history.  Most are from the same period and place.  This one had the distinction of being set late in 19th century America amongst the hustle and bustle of New York City.  Famous personages roaming freely amongst the author’s original characters and a twisting mystery and a little romance was just the thing.

This is the second book in the Mary Handley series.  While there were several references to the earlier case, there was no spoilers for it and also there was little connection so this could be read as a standalone.

The story opens with new woman, Mary Handley, attempting to lead an independent life in a time when the majority of women married and worked in the home.  Mary is sharp, confident, capable, and desirous of being taken seriously as a lady detective even if her mother disapproves, her brother is jealous, and her father faintly encourages her.  She has found a sponsor of sorts with the owner of the book shop where she works part-time and also keeps an office for her detective agency in his back room.  After the notoriety of her successfully solving a previous case and helping out the police, she now twiddles her thumbs waiting for the next case.

And it comes in the form of a lady from Richmond, Virginia, hiring her to prove that her uncle was killed by his wife before she moved up the social class ladder to wed powerful Collis Huntington.  Mary is eager to take the case even though her old mentor and her own good sense caution her about taking on the Huntingtons who are powerful and wealthy.

But others have plots and plans going on in the shadows working around Mary’s case.  Collis Huntington and other great men of business empires battle over the annexation of Brooklyn to New York and other plots to bring each other down.  Her brother is assigned the murder case of an older reclusive woman which brings a brutal killer out to keep the Handleys from getting close.  An actress is found dead and Mary’s own case takes a turn for the bizarre.  New York’s high society comes to call when debonair George Vanderbilt finds Mary delightful and offers to detect alongside her as her assistant.

When her brother is framed for murder and someone is pulling the strings of the justice system, Mary must work even harder and faster to solve the several murders and secrets she has on her plate.  George is there and supportive, but Mary can feel the wolves snapping at her heels.  Now’s her big chance and there is a lot riding on it.

This book left me with mixed feelings.  On one level, I enjoyed it, but alongside my enjoyment was also some reservations.  I thought the author did a stellar job of setting, blending history and fiction, and authentic dialogue.  The mystery was well done and kept me entertained.

It gets off to a slow start with me struggling to connect with the story.  There were a handful of narrative threads that seem to be running parallel to each other setting up the situations and introducing the large cast of characters, but eventually the reader starts to see how they connect and intersect as the story picks up the pace and gets going.

I had a hard time settling into the style of the writing.  It felt stilted and it kept me at arm’s length so I could never fully engage.  There were some potentially emotional scenes and those were the ones that drew me in the most, but even then I wasn’t fully immersed.

Then there was Mary, herself.  I both liked and didn’t like her.  Her ‘know it all’ attitude and prejudices against the wealthy (which she denied though her thoughts and actions prove her wrong) were a turn off.  The author made her vulnerable in the sense that she made a few errors and she was remorseful and learned from them.  But generally, she is convinced that she is all that.  I did find her humorous many times when she got a bit stuck up about her superior intelligence).  And to be fair, I would assume any woman trying to buck tradition and society’s rules about women would have to be pretty gutsy and strong-minded with a solid belief in herself.

For all my prickles toward Mary, her adventures were entertaining and she drew some interesting men in as admirers or haters.  She was the sort that people admired or hated because she does everything with conviction and this I admired her for.  I did cheer her on and wanted her to succeed as the underdog against some pretty powerful folk.

The backdrop is fascinating with details about true happenings and people of the time.  The society, culture, and innovations of that time period were well depicted.  I felt like I was there with the way the author deftly set the scenes.

In the end, though there were things that drew away from my pleasure, I would claim this as an enjoyable read.  I would recommend this to those who enjoy historicals set at the nineteenth century with a strong mystery and a mild romance.

I received this book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.

Challenges Met:

Romance Roundabout #17 HR
Literary Pickers #17 business cards
New to Me #8 author/series

0 0 votes
Article Rating
The following two tabs change content below.
I was born and raised near Sacramento, CA. I have read since I was four years old and developed tastes that run the gamut of literature. I went away to college and have a degree in education, a certificate in family history research, and a certificate in social work. I worked for a non-profit agency with low income families for 20 years which included being responsible for the children’s library and promoting/teaching adult literacy. I have lived in Southeast Michigan for the last 18 years and I am currently a book addicted homemaker with a cat and husband who keep me grounded. Recently, I made it a challenge to review each book that I have read as a favor to author friends who said reviews are important. I have done reviews for Good Reads, Amazon, eBay, and Smashwords, but mostly at Goodreads and Amazon.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
6 years ago

This one sounds full of mystery and conflict. Almost too much, in my opinion. This one is not for me. Great review!

Sophia Rose
6 years ago
Reply to  Lekeisha

It was a pretty busy story and had my head spinning a few times. I finally saw all the connections at the end. Not sure how I feel about the series, either.

6 years ago

While I’m not a fan of the cover, (lol), I actually like reading about strong, independent women in that century, and her adventures sound fun. Great Review! Hugs…

Sophia Rose
6 years ago
Reply to  RO

You should see the first books cover. LOL

I am so picky about the gals. She probably would come across differently for others and its just me being touchy.

Thanks for popping by, Ro!

6 years ago

That is a lot of fire

Sophia Rose
6 years ago
Reply to  Blodeuedd

Oh yeah. One of the villains is a pyro so it makes sense with the story.

Anna@herding cats&burning soup

Hmmm yeah I can totally see mixed feelings over that one. I love the time frame of it. I’ve not read many with that so it is intriguing that way but the standoffish writing style makes me a little wary.

Sophia Rose
6 years ago

Yeah. The time frame was definitely what pulled me in, but I never got used to the author’s style. It was fiction, but it read like textbook if that makes sense.

Anna@herding cats&burning soup
Reply to  Sophia Rose

Oh yes. Makes total sense. I’ve had them that felt like a text book or instruction manual almost. Not the style for me personally.

Sophia Rose
6 years ago

Yeah, it was tough b/c I liked the story line and the setting. Oh well.

Mary Kirkland
6 years ago

Sounds like a good one for those who enjoy historicals.

Sophia Rose
6 years ago
Reply to  Mary Kirkland

Yes, it was not such a good one for the romance, but the historical side was interesting.

Melanie Simmons
6 years ago

Sorry you didn’t enjoy this one more, but glad it wasn’t too bad for you. I don’t think it would be for me. Great review Sophia.

Sophia Rose
6 years ago

Yeah, I think I was looking for more emotional engagement and romance and this was more historical fiction. I liked it, but didn’t love it.

6 years ago

That sounds like a fun time period and setting. I am glad to hear the mystery was well doen and kept you interested. I always find that very important in a mystery book. That’s too bad about the slow start and difficulty connectign with the story. And while it might make sense for a women like her to have a know it all attitude, I can also see how that would get old fast. I haven’t read a historical mystery so far, maybe I should add that to my list of genres i should try to read more of. Great… Read more »

Sophia Rose
6 years ago
Reply to  Lola

Yes, the time period and the setting were really well written. I could picture how it all was. The mystery had me all twisted around at times so that was good. Mary tended to get bossy. That part was hard. She was right a lot of times, but it was how she went about it that rubbed me wrong.

It would be interesting to see what you think about historical mysteries. I tend to like them better than contemporary ones most of the time.