Review: Old West Collection by Carla Kelly, Sarah A. Eden, Liz Adair, Heather B. Moore, Marsh Ward, and Annette Lyons

Posted March 4, 2018 by Sophia Rose in Reviews / 14 Comments

Tags: , , , , , ,

Review: Old West Collection by Carla Kelly, Sarah A. Eden, Liz Adair, Heather B. Moore, Marsh Ward, and Annette Lyons
Old West Collection
Narrated by Siiri Scott

One StarOne StarOne StarHalf a Star

Series: A Timeless Collection #7
Genres: Western Romance
Published by Brilliance Audio
Released on September 25, 2017
Length: 10 hrs and 2 mins
Format: Audiobook
Source: Publisher
add to goodreads

The Delight

I enjoyed the Regency Collection so when the Old West Collection became available in audio, I had to listen to those novellas.


Like many anthologies can be, this was something of a mixed bag.  I tried to say a little something of my impressions about each story.

Break A Leg by Carla Kelly
4 stars

I can always count on this author for writing a non-typical historical whether its Regency England, the high seas, or the Old West.  In this case, her Irish hero is a non-commissioned medical officer and he’s in love with a competent, calm bi-racial family maid for a heroine on a frontier outpost in the waning days of the Wild West.  I thought this was a sweet story though a little slower in the beginning while building the back story (which was a necessary tough) since this pair have sad pasts and it has a baring on the present which is more the culmination of their story rather than a beginning.  Loved it!

The Soldier’s Heart by Sarah M. Eden
4 stars

Gregory has a crush on his deceased best friend’s sister based entirely on the woman he meets and learns to love through her letters to her brother.  He is all fumbling around her when he meets her, but she is rather taken with him as is the rest of the family on the farm.  He leads with a lie of omission that he is fearful of resolving because he’s afraid of how she’ll react to the truth.
It was sweet with the orphan kids and the slow building romance.  it was somewhat rushed at the end.

Hidden Spring  by Liz Adair
3 stars

The heroine, Susanna, is a spitfire with a haughty attitude trying to get past losing her husband and learning to live independently.  I never quite warmed up to her rudeness  in the beginning that seemed to just come out of left field.  Douglas is a little rough, but he’s kind and didn’t deserve her attitude which is reserved solely for him.  I did like seeing their hesitant courtship and the work around the ranch.

The Silver Mine Bachelor by Heather B. Moore
2 stars

Prim and Proper Lydia has moved to Leadville on a husband hunt and has taken up the job of mine owner’s secretary.  Her boss intrigues her, but his connection to a brothel has her hesitating.  The idea of a husband hunt is cute, but I just couldn’t get into Lydia and her stuck up attitude toward other people from the first moment she sits in her church pew and scratches guys off her list for things like dirt under his finger nails or a bad suit coat.  Hello, these are miners and this isn’t NYC.  I would have been fine if she was nervous or unsure being near prostitutes since she’s sheltered, but she comes across as sanctimonious and that I couldn’t like.   The parson’s attitudes in this one didn’t set well with me, either, refusing to go at the request of a man to try to speak to a sickly woman because she’s a prostitute.  Loved the hero, Eric Dawson, and his tender care for his sick sister.  The mining world of Leadville was well drawn.  But overall, it was not for me.

The Sweetest Taste by Annette Lyon
4 Stars

A farm girl dreaming of big city lights gets her opportunity even if it means leaving the young man behind who loves, but learns quickly that the city isn’t all she imagined.  Suddenly the comparisons are going the other way and she has to rethink her choice.  I thought this was sweet and heartwarming best friends to lovers with lovely nods to the time period for the country and the city.

Faith and the Foreman by Marsha A. Ward
4 stars

Oh how nice, Faith and Slim’s romance comes with a mystery for them to figure out- why is Slim’s boss getting sick and who’s stealing the man’s cattle.  Faith is a sweet gentle soul and Slim gets through one dance at the social before realizing she’s one special lady and he wants to get to know her better.  Cute characters and a bit of humor to this heartwarming tale.

I experienced the Old West Collection on audio.  Siiri Scott was a first time narrator for me.  I was very distracted by her narrative style.  She heavily enunciates each syllable and her voicings of men or children and some women sounded a little off.  I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the haughty, snippiness I sensed in some of the stories would not have come through as such if I had read these.  She did have solid female voices like for Ozzy in the first story or Faith in the last.  I thought she had a good sense of timing.

All in all, this was another engaging collection of sweet historical romance stories with a good variety of western settings and characters.

My thanks to Brilliance Audio for the opportunity to listen to these in exchange for an honest review.


Romance Roundabout #50 HR
Literary Pickers #46 barn
Mt. TBR #30
Blogger Shame #1
Audio #9


0 0 votes
Article Rating
The following two tabs change content below.
I was born and raised near Sacramento, CA. I have read since I was four years old and developed tastes that run the gamut of literature. I went away to college and have a degree in education, a certificate in family history research, and a certificate in social work. I worked for a non-profit agency with low income families for 20 years which included being responsible for the children’s library and promoting/teaching adult literacy. I have lived in Southeast Michigan for the last 18 years and I am currently a book addicted homemaker with a cat and husband who keep me grounded. Recently, I made it a challenge to review each book that I have read as a favor to author friends who said reviews are important. I have done reviews for Good Reads, Amazon, eBay, and Smashwords, but mostly at Goodreads and Amazon.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
3 years ago

Almost all really good so it’s great! That’s great for an anthology

Sophia Rose
3 years ago
Reply to  Melliane

Yes, this was an ‘almost’ one. 🙂

3 years ago

It’s always a mixed bag with anthologies though it seems you enjoyed most of them. I would’ve had the same issue with the one with the sanctimonious heroine. That’s a turn off for me.

Sophia Rose
3 years ago
Reply to  Evie

Yes, it was mostly full of cute and light romance in various Old West setting. Ugh, yes, I didn’t take to that one heroine. 🙂

Mary Kirkland
3 years ago

Anthologies can be fun and it sounds like most of the stories were pretty good.

Sophia Rose
3 years ago
Reply to  Mary Kirkland

Definitely! There were some cute ones particularly the first and last story. I’m definitely looking for more of these authors’ books.

Carole's Random Life
3 years ago

This looks like a pretty good anthology with most stories being good. Too bad the narrator had some issues with voicing some of the characters. Glad you enjoyed this overall.

Sophia Rose
3 years ago

I’ve been pretty lucky with anthologies and even narrators so that’s okay that I miss on one now and then. 🙂

Bookworm Brandee
Bookworm Brandee
3 years ago

This might sound ridiculous but I’d never thought about *listening* to an anthology! This one does seem like it was good overall. I’m particularly curious about Break a Leg and The Soldier’s Heart. It’s too bad The Silver Mine Bachelor didn’t do much for you. Leadville is a neat little town. 🙂

Sophia Rose
3 years ago

I hesitated for the longest time b/c I thought it might be confusing starting in one story and stopping at a point in another one each time. And, that still happens a little, but I think b/c these are novellas so a little longer and its not too many stories that I can keep things straight.

The descriptions of Leadville as a mining town were some of the best parts. I will have to visit through that area some day.

3 years ago

I grew up reading romance novels, so this is right up my alley. It sounds really good.

Sophia Rose
3 years ago
Reply to  Cricket

Glad to put you onto this set, Cricket. I have a soft spot for old-style romances, too.

Anna@herding cats&burning soup

Not bad overall it seems. The Soldier’s Heart I think would get me.

Sophia Rose
3 years ago

Oh yes! A war-weary soldier trying to find his way with a sweet lady. Swoony!